Yesterday I had a great time discussing the differences between socialism and capitalism with my son. He was working his way through a project in college comparing the two, and I thought some of the parallels we drew would make great talking points when caught in a discussion with a liberal, socialist minded citizen.
Being a college athlete we applied socialism to sports, something he's overly familiar with. If socialism was applied to the field, we wouldn't keep score. The professional athletes would all be paid the same salary, as we'd try to make everything the a level playing field for players and spectators. We'd have to constantly move our seats as spectators so everyone could enjoy equal views of the field, and the price to get in would be free. There would be no competition on the field as there is no incentive to score.
Proponents of this system will point out how wonderful it is to attend a sporting event for free, that everyone has a great seat, and no one's feelings get hurt by losing. While this utopia has it's point, in reality it'd be boring, and bankrupt, except the government is going to tax you to support it. Kind of like the federal subsidy we give to the endowment of the arts in real life.
Now to highlight capitalism in sports today there is one model that stands out. Love them, or hate them, the New York Yankees emulate capitalism! George Steinbrenner has assembled a team of high dollar talent that seldom fails to disappoint. Their result is evident by the numerous World Series rings they possess. From the coaching staff to the players, the team is expected to win, and everyone is paid accordingly. Exciting plays are made on the field as there is an economic incentive to excel. Players enjoy higher endorsement , and memorabilia contracts, because the fans love winners. The stadium seats command a higher ticket price, as you know your going to be entertained.
The principles of socialism discourage competition in the name of equality. While all men are created equal, they are not. We take great care to ensure they get equal opportunity, but their results are directly proportionate to the effort they apply. In professional sports the best talent take the field, it's one of the few places you'll never see affirmative action applied, another socialist ideal. While Detroit Lion's fans might like a dose of socialism, the rest of us prefer competition, and having the best qualified team win. This is what stirs the souls of men, and creates exceptionalism. When two teams of exceptional individuals meet we have competition. Competition defines winners and losers. Winners create a passion in all of us to excel. Losers look forward to the next match, better for the learning experience.
Socialist's revel in mediocrity!
God Bless!
Capt. Bill
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment